As crianças americanas sabidamente preferem o suco de maçã ao de laranja, o que motivou um grupo de pesquisadores a investigar se esse hábito poderia determinar diferenças ao interferir na absorção do ferro da dieta. O estudo que testou a hipótese está publicado no periódico Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, e conclui que não existem diferenças significativas entre a absorção do elemento entre o uso dos dois sucos.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine
Effect of Orange and Apple Juices on Iron Absorption in Children
Malika Shah, MD; Ian J. Griffin, MB, ChB; Carlos H. Lifschitz, MD; Steven A. Abrams, MD
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2003;157:1232-1236.
Objective To measure iron absorption in children from meals containing apple juice or orange juice so as to determine if iron absorption will be greater with orange juice because of its higher ascorbic acid content than apple juice, a noncitrus fruit juice that US children reportedly prefer.
Design On 2 successive days, children consumed identical meals that included apple juice on one day and orange juice on the other, in random order. The meals were labeled with iron-57 on one day and iron-58 on the other. Iron absorption was measured from red blood cell incorporation of the iron stable isotopes 14 days later.
Setting Nutrition research institute in a major metropolitan medical center.
Patients A total of 25 healthy children, 3 to 6 years of age, were recruited, of whom 21 (11 male and 10 female) completed the study.
Intervention Identical meals served with orange juice and apple juice were given on consecutive days, in a balanced randomized design.
Main Outcome Measures Iron absorption measured by established stable isotope methods.
Results Median iron absorption from the meal ingested with apple juice was 7.17% (mean ± SD, 9.48% ± 9.68%). Median iron absorption from the meal ingested with orange juice was 7.78% (9.80% ± 6.66%; P = .44). Iron absorption from the meal that included apple juice was significantly correlated with serum ferritin concentration (P = .02); iron absorption from the meal that included orange juice tended to correlate with serum transferrin receptor concentration (P = .051).
Conclusions As children absorb iron well from a meal that includes either orange or apple juice, a preference for apple juice does not pose a concern with regard to the prospect of iron-deficiency anemia, which remains a significant health problem in the United States.
From the Section of Neonatology, Department of Pediatrics (Drs Shah, Griffin, and Abrams), Section of Gastroenterology and Nutrition, Department of Pediatrics (Dr Lifschitz), and US Department of Agriculture/Agricultural Research Service Children's Nutrition Research Center (Drs Shah, Griffin, Lifschitz, and Abrams), Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Tex.
